That set sounds really good. Snares? I dig the deep Ludwig Coliseum (I just have never liked the look of COW., but that's my problem) But if you are REALLY going to compare, how about the snares off sound, cross stick, and brushes on all of them.
And yeah, "I love them all for different reasons," the mantra for a SD junkie in his infancy. Just. Walk. Away.
As inappropriate as it is for a cute 'lil bop kit like that, the Collesium takes it for me: very (dare I say "Super"?) sensitive, great dynamic and tonal range. A close second is the brass Gretsch. More sensitive than I expected (and I've owned one of them for 32 years), yet not too crisp. Some good rich tones.
On a good day in the right room, though, I'll bet that matching Slingy's gonna sound just like home!