I think it stems from the very wide age range of the members here along with musical interests and how both of those along with social influences have shaped their development over the years. There is nothing wrong with having an opinion of course, but we get asked a very broad question "What do you wear when playing drums at a gig" and all of those different influences and opinions get dropped in the same thread.Not directed at you personally, honest. Just looking through the whole thread there are numerous reactions, and it's come up in the past too. I guess I'm just curious why the subject still provokes such a strong reaction as it's not something new. Didn't mean to single anyone out.
From some of the posts here, there are people that would cringe seeing what I wear to a gig, but it's appropriate for the style of music I play, my comfort level, region that I live in etc... I would never be comfortable wearing say, a suit and tie or anything considered formal, but I have to read those responses and probably assume they don't play the same style(s) that I do. So I take it with a grain of salt and just chalk it up to a difference in style and opinion.
But I do agree, statements that start with "never", "don't do (whatever", and "how can ...." that are more directive than self reflective should just be dismissed, because I believe they are counterproductive in nature.