OT: Auditioning Guitarists: A LOT of Work!

  • Thread starter DrumBob
  • Start date
  • This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links like Ebay, Amazon, and others.

DrumBob

DFO Star
Gold Supporting Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2005
Messages
9,302
Reaction score
931
Location
northwest NJ
I'm in the process of looking for a replacement for my second guitarist, who is amicably leaving the band 11/1. He doesn't like the direction we're going in, which is newer, more recognizable material. OK, fine. I like the guy, but he's lost in the sixties. He wants to play Gerry & The Pacemakers stuff. Go figure.

I have ads all over the Internet and going into the local music rag this week. I have spoken to about 15 guitarists so far. We've had one guy come down to audition. Over the phone he tells me he's into Mick Taylor, Eric Clapton, Leslie West, Paul Kossoff. Great. He comes down and immediately starts playing Eddie Van Halen licks with that awful pinched, compressed tone that I hate. Scratch him off the list.

Then, I get a Deadhead. He sends me to his website and the idiot already has two bands, a Dead tribute, and a Phish tribute. Puh-leeeze. Go away! No Dead music allowed in my band.

Then there was the mercenary. First question out of his mouth is, "How much do the gigs pay." See ya later, alligator.

Then, there was the doofus who couldn't dial my phone number correctly even after I gave it to him twice.

Then, there was the lawyer from Upper Saddle River (an extremely affluent town), who, when questioned as to whether he sang, replied, "Well, yes, but you would be the best judge as to whether or not I sounded good." He also told me he hadn't played in a band in 20 years. Exit, stage left.

Then, there was another lawyer who was pretty much only interested in the money. Don't you make anough being a lawyer?

Then, there were the 9 or so guys who sound promising. Two are coming down Thursday night. Two more next Wednesday, and on we go. I have a feeling that we'll know the "right guy" when he appears. Kind of like meeting your future wife. You just know.

Here's another interestiung thing; my bro-in-law plays guitar and sings pretty well and used to play in bands but hasn't for years. He wants a shot at the gig. I agreed, but told him he would be treated like any other guy auditioning, that I couldn't show favoritism.

Needless to say, it's been an interesting couple of weeks and promises to become more interesting still.
 
Just over a year ago, my band was hunting for a lead player. Perhaps we got lucky, but I think a big part of it was the ad we put out there. We were very detailed in describing what we want out of a guitar sound and in citing names of players who push our buttons -- often obscure players who aren't everyday, household names (e.g. Gurf Morlix). That helped screen only the serious contenders. The more compelling the ad, the more interesting the responders. Anyway, best of luck. Guitar is an evocative instrument. Hope you land on someone who fits the bill soon...
 
Craig's list has produced reputable players for some friends of mine.
 
This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links like Ebay, Amazon, and others.
Hi Bob. As a drummer guitarist your job here is certainly a mixed blessing.I measure a guitarmans worth by the three 'T"s : TONE TASTE TIME. Also a singing guitarist has an advantage.Also grooming is important since the individual is out front. Presentable? Smiles at the audience?Actually a female guitarist is more desirable if certain criteria are to be considered. I dont envy your job,so good luck and keep us posted.BennyK.
 
Good Morning Bob,
I know where you are on this. We just had our lead guitarist leave us. Everybody is cool with it. I found two possibilities, one didn't want to travel for rehearsal, the other one showed up for one rehearsal, was offered the job but so far has had excuses for not being able to rehearse. I went to a blues festival a couple of weeks ago and happened to see a couple of musicians I have known for years. They provided me with a name of a guitarist whom I knew. I contacted him, brought him to a rehearsal and now we have offered him the job. Guess what ? The " new " guitarist used to live about a half of a block away from me when he was in school !!!!!! I went to school with his parents and played music for years with his uncle.
The moral of all this is:
# 1 Network with other musicians, it's possible they know of available players
# 2 Always look in your own backyard, it' amazing what you will find
Good luck on your search
Dave
 
dead_head said:
DrumBob said:
Then, I get a Deadhead.


Not biting on this one....

I'll try to take a tip from you...always bugs me how Deadheads (and by association, Phishheads) get looked down upon by musicians. Both bands have tons of good music, and that's taking out the improvisations. Say what you will, but you can't find a better songwriting team than Garcia/Hunter. As good yes, but better? Never. And that's all I'll say about that. 8)
 
Lennon/McCartney, Rodgers/Hart, Rodgers/Hammerstein, George & Ira Gershwin, Duke Ellington/Billy Strayhorn...your boys have some strong competition...
 
Velociamator said:
Lennon/McCartney, Rodgers/Hart, Rodgers/Hammerstein, George & Ira Gershwin, Duke Ellington/Billy Strayhorn...your boys have some strong competition...
ditto. And I love the Grateful Dead.
 
Bob,

Maybe you should let some/most of these guys audition first. The chemistry happens when the music starts. I don't neccessarily get along, or have had loads in common with many players over the years, but IMHO, we have managed to put out some pretty decent music. Guys/gals our age have had many years to develope some pretty odd characteristics. :lol:

Maybe you should give these guys a chance and not be so judgemental by your first impression.

Good luck.
 
Velociamator said:
Lennon/McCartney, Rodgers/Hart, Rodgers/Hammerstein, George & Ira Gershwin, Duke Ellington/Billy Strayhorn...your boys have some strong competition...


I won't disagree that those are all up there with Garcia/Hunter, but I don't think a one of'em has written anything better. As good, most certainly, but not better.

I won't say everything they've done is perfect (they did write Day Job, after all), but Uncle John's Band, Scarlet Begonias, Ripple, Bird Song, all just magical stuff.
 
I REALLY, REALLY dislike the Grateful Dead-bordering on hate. I admit it, I don't understand the hype. The music does absolutely nothing for me, so it must be the culture surrounding the music that is the big appeal. (Anyone seen my roach clip?) :drunken:

Bob, I'm with ya on this one!
 
Back
Top